The new series would be called The New Mutants, and it would introduce a new group of teenage students for Xavier to mentor. The X-Men had long since strayed from their original conception as a school for mutants, having taken on older members like Banshee and Wolverine and become a more standard superteam battling world-threatening menaces.
Issue one of the new series, written by Chris Claremont with art by Bob McLeod and Mike Gustovich, starts off a little confusing, with the group already established, although they obviously don’t know each other very well yet. Marvel had tried a new approach, debuting the group in a Marvel Graphic Novel before launching the series. Not having read the graphic novel, I always felt a little behind the curve while reading the series, even though I stuck with it for most of 60 issues.
That feeling was partly caused by the almost substanceless first issue. The story had to bring new readers like me up to speed on the characters and their relationships, but without the benefit of a strong story structure like you would have in a standalone graphic novel. The new faces sort of mill around and argue, and then have Danger Room workouts to demonstrate their powers and personalities.
Which points up another problem of the original team: unlike the X-Men, who really seemed to be set up as a fighting team, the New Mutants were combat light. Aside from super-strong Sunspot and invulnerable Cannonball, the group included:
- * Wolfsbane, who turned into a wolf, and not even a magical werewolf
- * Karma, who possessed people
- * And Mirage, who could project images of people’s thoughts.
Not exactly the line-up you need when you’re fighting Sentinels.
I really liked McLeod’s art on the series. His stuff was always laid out and structured well, really solid drawing with just enough detail. But for whatever reason (and I’m guessing deadlines), he only lasted three issues as penciller. Issue four saw Marvel stalwart Sal Buscema take over the pencils, with McLeod inking to keep a more consistent feel with what had gone before.
Buscema stayed on through issue 17, but the book felt more solid than some of his other work at the time, because they kept him with interesting inkers–Tom Mandrake and Kim DeMulder–who weren’t afraid to dress up his breakdowns.
Meanwhile, Claremont changed the composition of the team to bring in more combat power. Karma was written out, and a newer new mutant named Magma was brought in to provide literal firepower. Colossus’s sister Illyana, now known as Magik, was also added.
And then came issue 18, and the book’s real leap into prominence. Sal Buscema left and was replaced by Bill Sienkiewicz, who promptly took the art in a more experimental direction. I had written Sienkiewicz off long ago as a second-rate Neal Adams imitator, but in The New Mutants, Sienkiewicz fused several disparate influences, including classic American animation and Ralph Steadman‘s disquieting work, into something completely unique.
For instance, this sequence from his first issue in which Mirage battles the nightmarish demon bear which murdered her parents.
There’s none of Adams’s realism about the bear. It’s just an ominous looming shape with angry jagged edges. Sienkiewicz only stayed on the book for about a year, but during that time, he attracted a lot of attention, not just to his own experimental style, but also to this second-string team of mutants and their increasingly strange adventures. Another team member was added, an alien shapeshifter named Warlock who was suited to Sienkiewicz’s strengths. And at the end of Sienkiewicz’s run, an old face made a reappearance, this time as a villain (temporarily, at least).
Kind of a crazy misstep for Claremont, having one of the group’s founding members turn evil because she got fat (or something–it apparently happened in another book I didn’t read, and I’ve only been skimming these old issues, so I can’t tell you what actually happened).
After Sienkiewicz left, the book never seemed to settle down with a stable creative team. Steve Leialoha did a few issues, Jackson Guice did a few issues, as well as June Brigman. Keith Pollard, Kevin Nowlan, Rick Leonardi and Sal Buscema (again) all did fill-in issues.
Chris Claremont left with issue 55 and the book took on a new creative team, with Louise Simonson writing and Bret Blevins on pencils. Only a few issues later, Marvel launched into their big “Fall of the Mutants” event, which killed off several characters (this just a year after the “Mutant Massacre” which had killed or crippled a bunch more, including Colossus and Nightcrawler of the X-Men). The whole thing left a bad taste in my mouth. I quit The New Mutants with issue #61, and quit X-Men, and pretty much Marvel entirely, a few issues later.